The Discernment Chart

by Sister Julie on February 13, 2009

In yesterday’s post on 4 Steps for Discernment and Decision-Making, Sister Mary noted in Step 2 that you can create a kind of chart to help you figure out how you feel about a decision that you have to make.

I thought I’d give you an example of what that chart might look like for the question, Should I go to graduate school or not?
discern-chart

The pros and cons don’t have to seem like significant reasons, they just have to be important to us. I remember when I had to choose a high school, I ended up going to one because their basketball uniforms looked more cool than the other school’s. Now it wasn’t my only reason, but that desire encapsulated for me all that I felt about the school and that I could envision myself in that school, with those people, and, of course, in that uniform!

Try making a chart for yourself. Consider something in your life that requires you to make a decision. It might be big, it might be small. Try it out and be attentive to the guidance that Sister Mary gives on discernment. Let us know how it goes.

What questions or observations do you have for Sister Mary McDevitt, IHM, in preparation for our online discussion with Sister Mary this Sunday, February 15, from 7-9 p.m. EST?

Email This Post Email This Post Print This Post Print This Post

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Jill, ihm February 13, 2009 at 8:38 pm

This works. It really really works. Last summer, I was faced with two equally compelling opportunities, but it was impossible for me to do both—I couldn’t be in Philadelphia and San Francisco on the same weekend!! So, at the suggestion of a good friend, I did a ‘pro/con’ chart like the one above. And seeing my reasons on paper really helped to make it clear where I needed to be for that weekend. It allowed me to own my decision, and to be certain that I was making the right choice for the right reasons.

2 discerninglife25 February 14, 2009 at 10:25 am

A few questions:
1) Why is there a Call? How do you know if it is valid? What are some characteristics of a Call?
2) What are some characteristics of a good discernment to religious life?
3) How do you know you will be happy in religious life?
Thanks!

Pax Tibi,
Discerninglife25

3 Sister Julie February 14, 2009 at 12:22 pm

Thanks, Sister Jill! I remember way back when I was discerning and Sister Mary told me about the chart. One of the best things I ever learned. I find it helpful in a variety of decision-making situations.

Good questions, DL25. Will pass those along to Sister Mary.

4 Lisa Burke February 15, 2009 at 8:20 am

My only caveat about a pro/con chart is to bear in mind that it is not the number of items on each list or the length of the list but the quality and value of the items on the list. In other words, I have found that I may only have two or three pros on a list and twice or three times as many cons but the value of the two pros so outweighs the cons that it is clear that I should do whatever it is I am discerning/evaluating.

Peace,
Lisa

5 Sister Julie February 15, 2009 at 9:14 am

Good observation, Lisa. You’re absolutely right.

6 Dita February 25, 2009 at 3:55 pm

I just recently spent time with an order three days, it was a beautiful retreat… I felt very at home and very peaceful, while praying for two hours one night, I didn’t want to leave!
I have and still am discerning now my third year…
I feel if I never try religious life.. i will always wonder if I would have been truly called?
does this make any sense??
I am 21 years old and am graduating in one year.
I would like to join an order once I am done with school.

Leave a Comment